There is debate about whether marijuana (cannabis) use is more dangerous than alcohol use. Although difficult to make objective comparisons, research is needed to compare relative dangers in order to help inform preventive efforts and policy.
Data were analyzed from a nationally representative sample of high school seniors in the Monitoring the Future study (2007–2011; Weighted n = 7437; modal age: 18) who reported lifetime use of alcohol or marijuana. Students were asked to indicate whether they experienced various adverse psychosocial outcomes resulting from use of each substance. We examined which outcomes were more prevalent for each substance.
Compared to alcohol use, marijuana use was more commonly reported to compromise relationships with teachers or supervisors, result in less energy or interest, and result in lower school or job performance. Compared to marijuana use, alcohol was more commonly reported to compromise relationships with friends and significant others; it was also reported to lead to more regret (particularly among females), and driving unsafely. Marijuana users were more likely to report no adverse outcomes. Females and white students were more likely to report various adverse outcomes and higher frequency use of each substance also increased occurrences of reported adverse outcomes.
Marijuana and alcohol are associated with unique adverse psychosocial outcomes. Outcomes differ by sex and race/ethnicity, and perception or experience of outcomes may also be related to legal status and associated stigma. Public health interventions may be more effective by focusing on harm reduction strategies for these drug-specific outcomes.
(n = 3348)
(n = 3564)
(n = 2209)
(n = 2084)
|Caused you to behave in ways that you later regretted||31.4||41.9||61.4***||11.0||14.4||7.9|
|Hurt your relationship with your parents||8.8||13.0||23.4***||12.3||13.2||0.5|
|Hurt your relationship with your spouse, fiancée, or girlfriend/boyfriend||9.6||15.6||42.9***||9.0||13.1||13.2**|
|Hurt your relationships with your friends||6.7||11.7||39.1***||6.8||10.3||12.8**|
|Hurt your relationships with teachers or supervisors||1.8||2.3||1.6||2.1||4.1||10.0*|
|Involved you with people you think are a bad influence on you||8.9||15.1||48.9***||17.6||24.4||22.0***|
|Hurt your performance in school and/or on the job||4.6||6.5||8.6||10.0||11.2||1.1|
|Caused you to be less interested in other activities than you were before||3.6||6.4||21.3***||10.3||14.0||10.5*|
|Caused you to be less stable emotionally||4.1||13.7||159.5***||4.6||9.9||33.5***|
|Caused you to have less energy||7.1||9.3||8.8||17.9||25.6||28.8***|
|Interfered with your ability to think clearly||18.8||26.6||45.9***||17.9||25.0||24.8***|
|Had other bad psychological effects||1.7||3.8||22.4***||3.1||7.1||27.7***|
|Caused your physical health to be bad||3.2||5.3||13.7**||3.8||6.0||8.2|
|Caused you to drive unsafely||9.9||8.6||2.7||5.9||7.1||2.1|
|Gotten you into trouble with the police||6.3||5.4||2.2||5.8||4.1||5.3|
|Caused you none of the above problems||11.8||11.6||0.1||15.7||12.4||7.3|
Rao-Scott Chi-squares each contain 1 degree of freedom. Utilizing the Bonferroni correction,
*p < 0.003,
**p < 0.001,
***p < 0.0001.
Full article at: http://goo.gl/22J5zy
By: Joseph J. Palamar, PhD, MPH,1,2,3 Michael Fenstermaker, BA,4 Dimitra Kamboukos, PhD,1 Danielle C. Ompad, PhD,2,3,5 Charles M. Cleland, PhD,3,6 and Michael Weitzman, MD4
1New York University Langone Medical Center, Department of Population Health, New York
2Center for Health, Identity, Behavior, and Prevention Studies, New York University, New York, USA
3Center for Drug Use & HIV Research, New York University, New York, USA
4Departments of Pediatrics and Environmental Medicine, New York University, New York, USA
5Department of Nutrition, Food Studies and Public Health, Steinhardt School of Culture, Education and Human Development, New York University, New York, USA
6College of Nursing, New York University, New York, USA
Address correspondence to Joseph J. Palamar, One Park Avenue, 7th Floor, New York, NY 10016, USA. Tel: +1 646 754 4980. Fax: +1 646 754 5209. Email: email@example.com
More at: https://twitter.com/hiv_insight